Amended
IN
Assembly
February 13, 2001 |
Amended
IN
Assembly
March 05, 2001 |
Amended
IN
Assembly
March 12, 2001 |
Amended
IN
Senate
March 22, 2001 |
Introduced by
Assembly Member
Keeley (Coauthor(s): Assembly Member Kehoe, Vargas, Wayne) (Coauthor(s): Senator Alpert, Bowen, Peace) |
January 16, 2001 |
(1)The existing restructuring of the electrical services industry within the Public Utilities Act provides for the establishment of an Independent System Operator and a Power Exchange as separately incorporated public benefit, nonprofit corporations. An Electricity Oversight Board (Oversight Board) is also established to oversee the Independent System Operator and the Power Exchange in order to ensure the success of electric industry restructuring and to ensure a reliable supply of electricity in the transition to a new market structure. The Oversight Board is granted various powers in order to carry out these purposes.
This bill would expand the authority of the Oversight Board to act on any matters made subject to the approval or determination by the Oversight Board under law, and to investigate any matter and otherwise act consistent with these provisions to ensure that the interests of California’s citizens and consumers are served, protected, and represented in relation to the electric transmission grid and generation system and related costs.
The bill would require that electric generation and transmission facilities be subject to various prescribed availability standards. The bill would require the Independent System Operator to annually prepare and submit to the Oversight Board a proposed protocol for the scheduling of transmission and generation equipment outages for the purpose of maintenance, repair, or upgrade, that is required to be reviewed, approved or revised by the Oversight Board after notice and public hearing. The bill would require the Independent System Operator to utilize the approved protocol for the purpose of scheduling maintenance or other planned outages of equipment and to submit a coordinated outage plan to the Oversight Board. The bill would require the Independent System Operator to develop and submit proposed generation facility maintenance criteria for approval by the Oversight Board after notice and public hearing. The bill would require the Independent System Operator to maintain records of generation facility outages and provide those records to the Oversight Board on a daily basis. The bill would require entities that own or operate certain electric generating facilities to provide reports on a monthly basis to the Oversight Board that identify any periods the facilities were unavailable to produce electricity or were available at reduced capacity. The bill would authorize the Independent System Operator and the Oversight Board to engage in audits or inspection of facilities that fail to comply with procedures, criteria, or standards established pursuant to these provisions. The bill would require owners or operators of generation or transmission facilities to provide the Independent System Operator and the Oversight Board with information and access to the facilities as necessary to accomplish reasonable audits and inspections. The bill would authorize the Oversight Board to assess a monetary penalty against an owner or operator of a facility found to have failed to comply with criteria, standards, or procedures established pursuant to these provisions. Since a violation of the Public Utilities Act is a crime under existing provisions of law, the bill would create a state-mandated local program by expanding the definition of a crime.
(2) The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Section 335 of the Public Utilities Code is
360.5.
(a) As used in this section, “department” means the Department of Water Resources.
(b)Until the requirements of subdivision (c) have been satisfied, short run avoided cost energy payments paid to nonutility power generators by an electrical corporation shall be based on a formula that reflects a starting energy price, adjusted monthly to reflect changes in a starting gas index price in relation to an average of current California natural gas border price indices. The starting energy price shall be based on 12-month averages of recent, pre-January 1, 1996, short-run avoided energy prices paid by each public utility electrical corporation to nonutility power generators. The starting gas index price shall be established as an average of index gas prices for the same annual periods.
(c)The short-run avoided cost energy payments paid to nonutility power generators by electrical corporations shall be based on the clearing price paid by the independent Power Exchange if (1) the commission has issued an order determining that the independent Power Exchange is functioning properly for the purposes of determining the short-run avoided cost energy payments to be made to nonutility power generators, and either (2) the fossil-fired generation units owned, directly or indirectly, by the public utility electrical corporation are authorized to charge market-based rates and the “going forward” costs of those units are being recovered solely through the clearing prices paid by the independent Power Exchange or from contracts with the Independent System Operator, whether those contracts are market-based or based on operating costs for particular utility-owned powerplant units and at particular times when reactive power/voltage support is not yet procurable at market-based rates at locations where it is needed, and are not being recovered directly or indirectly through any other source, or (3) the public utility electrical corporation has divested 90 percent of its gas-fired generation facilities that were operated to meet load in 1994 and 1995. However, nonutility power generators subject to this section may, upon appropriate notice to the public utility electrical corporation, exercise a one-time option to elect to thereafter receive energy payments based upon the clearing price from the independent Power Exchange.
(d)If a nonutility power generator is being paid short-run avoided costs energy payments by an electrical corporation by a firm capacity contract, a forecast as-available capacity contract, or a forecast as-delivered capacity contract on the basis of the clearing price paid by the independent Power Exchange as described in subdivision (c) above, the value of capacity in the clearing price, if any, shall not be paid to the nonutility power generator. The value of capacity in the clearing price, if any, equals the difference between the market clearing customer demand bid at the level of generation dispatched by the independent Power Exchange and the highest supplier bid dispatched.
(e)Short-run avoided energy cost payments made pursuant to this section are in addition to contractually specified capacity payments. Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect, modify or amend the terms and conditions of existing nonutility power generators’ contracts with respect to the sale of energy or capacity or otherwise.
(f)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the level of transition cost recovery provided to utilities under electric industry restructuring policies established by the commission.
(g)The term “going forward costs” shall include, but not be limited to, all costs associated with fuel transportation and fuel supply, administrative and general, and operation and maintenance; provided that, for purposes of this section, the following shall not be considered “going forward costs”: (1) commission-approved capital costs for capital additions to fossil-fueled powerplants, provided that such additions are necessary for the continued operation of the powerplants utilized to meet load and such additions are not undertaken primarily to expand, repower or enhance the efficiency of plant operations; or, (2) commission-approved operating costs for particular utility-owned powerplant units and at particular times when reactive power/voltage support is not yet procurable at market-based rates in locations where it is needed, provided that the recovery shall end on December 31, 2001.
amended to read:
In order to ensure that the interests of the people of California are served, a five-member Electricity Oversight Board is hereby created as provided in Section 336. For purposes of this chapter, any reference to the Oversight Board shall mean the Electricity Oversight Board. Its functions shall be all of the following:
(a)To oversee the Independent System Operator and the Power Exchange.
(b)(1)To exercise the exclusive right to decline to confirm the appointments of members of the governing board of the Independent System Operator.
(2)To determine the composition and terms of service and to exercise the exclusive right to decline to confirm the appointments of specific members of the governing board of the Power Exchange.
(c)To serve as an appeal board for majority decisions of the Independent System Operator governing board, as they relate to matters subject to exclusive state jurisdiction, as specified in Section 339.
(d)Those members of the Power Exchange governing board whose appointments the Oversight Board has the exclusive right to decline to confirm include proposed governing board members representing agricultural end users, industrial end users, commercial end users, residential end users, end users at large, nonmarket participants, and public interest groups.
(e)To act on any matters made subject to approval or determination by the Oversight Board under law.
(f)To investigate any matter and otherwise act consistent with this chapter to ensure that the interests of California’s citizens and consumers are served, protected, and represented in relation to the electric transmission grid and generation system and related costs.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that electric generation and transmission facilities are critical infrastructure and their predictable availability is essential to the public welfare.
(b)Electric generation and transmission facilities shall be subject to availability standards, in accordance with this section.
(c)Owners or operators of electric generating facilities in the State of California shall comply with all standards approved or established pursuant to this chapter.
(d)The Independent System Operator shall prepare and submit to the Oversight Board, a proposed protocol for the scheduling of transmission and generation equipment outages for the purposes of maintenance, repair, or upgrade. The Independent System Operator shall resubmit this protocol, including any proposed revisions of the protocol, at least annually. The Oversight Board shall review and approve or direct revision of the proposed protocol as it determines is appropriate and necessary to protect the public interest after notice and public hearing. The Independent System Operator shall utilize an approved protocol for the purpose of scheduling maintenance or other planned outages of equipment including the preparation of a coordinated outage plan. The Independent System Operator shall prepare and submit to the Oversight Board, a coordinated outage plan that shall be updated not less than once each quarter.
(e)The Independent System Operator shall develop and submit to the Oversight Board proposed generation facility maintenance criteria. The Oversight Board shall review the proposed generation maintenance criteria and approve or direct revision of the criteria as it determines necessary to protect the public interest after notice and public hearing.
(f)The Independent System Operator shall maintain records of generation facility outages and shall provide those records to the Oversight Board on a daily basis. Each entity that owns or operates an electric generating facility in California with a rated maximum combined capacity of 50 megawatts or greater for all units at a single location, shall provide a monthly report to the Independent System Operator and the Oversight Board that identifies any periods during the preceding month when the facility was unavailable to produce electricity or was available only at reduced capacity. The report shall identify the reasons for any such unavailability or reduced capacity.
(g)The Independent System Operator and the Oversight Board may engage in audits or inspection of facilities that fail to comply with procedures, criteria, or standards established pursuant to this section or for which compliance is in question. Owners or operators of generation or transmission facilities shall provide information and access to the Independent System Operator and the Oversight Board as necessary to accomplish reasonable audit or inspection. The Oversight Board may, on petition of the Independent System Operator or acting on its own motion, and after public notice and hearing, assess a monetary penalty against the owner or operator of a facility found to have failed to comply with criteria, standards, or procedures approved or established pursuant to this section.
No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.